Butcher was comfortable as pastor of Poca Baptist Church in Poca, W.V., for 12 years. Then God gave him a new calling, according to the Martinsburg Journal:
Three years ago, I was at the dinner table and God spoke deep in my heart and asked me for a sacrifice. I wish I could say I said 'yes' immediately. After months of prayer, I knew that if I truly believed, I had to trust Him. Once I said 'yes,' He revealed that the sacrifice He was asking of me was to leave the warm and comfortable Poca Baptist Church to start a church for people who have given up on God.
Butcher started his new church, NewPoint Church, with six members -- Butcher, his wife, and their four children. His goal for the church is to be "biblically faithful and culturally relevant". The church now is up to 25 members.